Insect vs. Imitation

Baetis Nymph (Insect) and size 20 Iron Lotus Variation (Imitation)





















All too often I find myself making the same mistake over and over again. I, like most, have a handful of reliable patterns that I am very confident in. I use them on most rivers, and more times than not they produce fish like a factory. However, on rivers that are heavily fished it is very important to fish flies that imitate the insects being selected for that day. Realistic patterns that are drab in color often do the best for me in tough situations when fish are being extra picky. I try to tie up, and carry a variety of realistic patterns that can be used in these situations. The available food for trout can change daily, or even hourly. Depending on the weather, time of year, and a thousand other variables, different insects become active at varying times. Stomach pumps and hand seines come in real handy when trying to figure out what the fish are preferring that day. Match things up right and you can expect your success to increase almost immediately.

Common River Routine:

Arrive and fish my confidence patterns. If they are working, great why change a good thing? Fish them until they stop producing.

If fishing is tough, take a seine sample of the river’s insects. Match your imitations to the real insects found. Then, fish hard until the first fish is caught.

Pump the stomach of the first fish and change fly patterns accordingly. Give those flies a valid effort before giving up on them.

Fish until success slows down, then pump another fish’s stomach. Change flies if the preferred food type has changes.

Note: Not every fish needs its stomach pumped. Only steal breakfast from one fish, lunch from another, and dinner from a third. If you can’t figure out how to catch fish by then, go home and build up some brownie points with the wife so you can go back and try again tomorrow.

There are many factors besides having the right fly that determine how many fish you catch. This is simple one more piece to the puzzle! Good luck, and tight lines!


Leave a Reply

* Copy This Password *

* Type Or Paste Password Here *

Find us on YouTube
Find us on Facebook